If your household uses a lot of light brown sugar, you may find yourself out of it right when you need it most. Then put the container in a shipping box and use crumpled newspaper or other filling materials to keep the container from moving around in the box. Regular chocolate chip cookies are a bonafide crowd-pleaser, but they don’t hold a candle to the texture, chew, and toasty flavor of its oatmeal counterpart.. The two types of brown sugar, light and dark, refer to the amount of molasses that is present. In the bowl of an electric mixer, beat together the butter and brown sugar on medium speed until creamy, about 3 minutes. Bake until the edges are slightly golden but the centers are still pale, 11 to 13 minutes. Choose this option if you want to reduce the molasses taste in your baked goods by cutting the dark brown sugar with white as a replacement for light brown. Position two racks in the middle of the oven and preheat to 350°F. Chewy with the perfect slightly crispy edges. Froze half of the batter for a treat another day. Hi Amy, I’m obviously weighing in too late to be helpful – I’m sorry! My 5-year old decided he wanted to help and before I could stop him, dumped (and mixed!) I’m done.” These are not your ordinary oatmeal cookies. Excellent recipe! Mix together the flour, salt, and baking soda in a medium sized bowl. • Light brown sugar includes 3.5% molasses and dark brown sugar almost twice that amount- 6.5%, but it is up to you to choose light or dark brown sugar in your recipes as they are similar in flavor. Step 1. Thank you, Jenn! Varying factors such as product types or brands purchased, natural fluctuations in fresh produce, and the way ingredients are processed change the effective nutritional information in any given recipe. Once upon a time, I went to culinary school and worked in fancy restaurants. The recipe calls for way fewer oats than most, which, strangely, makes for much better oatmeal cookies. Regretfully, I over cooked them, So they were not soft after they cooled, my mistake, should have followed the recommended time , still they were delicious Definitely will make them again! How did the cookies turn out? (Did … Dark brown sugar in the cookie really added such a nice almost caramel/butterscotch flavor. white chocolate chips, instant oatmeal, unsalted butter, light brown sugar and 6 more. Made exactly as written and they were perfection. Not sure about the baking time so keep a close eye on them. Hi Corinne, What brand of flour are you using? I added 1 tsp pumpkin pie spice (because it is October) and refrigerated the dough before cooking. Light brown sugar usually contains 3.5% molasses and dark brown sugar usually contains 6.5% Turbinado, Demerara and muscovado are three types of brown sugar commonly found in the market today. Who knew oatmeal cookies could be this good! When a recipe doesn't specify, use light brown sugar, which has a less pronounced molasses flavor. Success!! Literally the first time I haven’t been thrilled with one of Jenn’s recipes. Once cool, store the cookies in an air-tight container. light brown sugar, instant oats, vanilla extract, cookie butter and 3 more. These cookies are amazing!! Yes, I think it would be fine to add a little coconut. Hi Corinne, What brand of flour do you use? Replace each cup of packed light brown sugar with 2/3 cup of packed dark brown sugar and 1/3 cup white sugar. I made these! Though typically interchangeable, dark brown sugar has a higher concentration of molasses than light brown sugar. Optional toppings: Fresh berries and chopped nuts. I substituted dried Michigan cherries for the raisins. Trust me! It’s perfectly possible to make oatmeal cookies with no brown sugar on hand, even though it seems to be listed as an ingredient in virtually every recipe. I'd love to know how it turned out! (This statement probably doesn’t surprise many of you!) Hope your father enjoys! It's great for sprinkling on toast or oatmeal because it's dry and doesn't clump, but I don't recommend it for baking. In a medium saucepan, whisk together the milk, egg, sugar and butter over medium heat until smooth. I made them with chocolate chips instead of raisins since that’s all I had on hand, but I kept thinking they would be PERFECT with raisins. I did cook each batch for 14-15 minutes – 2 full baking sheets made about 4 dozen cookies the last time – I doubled the recipe after the first batch and freeze about 3 dozen cookies in separate sealing bags – 1 dozen in each bag. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/265505/maple-and-brown-sugar-oatmeal I used a mix of dark and milk chocolate chips for a little more interesting flavor. Thank you! Excellent cookies. The measurements are given in metric and this was a great help for me rather than in cups or sticks. I’ve been using a small batch farm organic flour. Thank you! This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. It is also a popular ingredient in body scrubs, because its granulated texture works to exfoliate dead skin cells and dirt form the skin’s surface, and the scent is pleasant. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper. Could it get any better than this??? Also, do you have any tips for the raisins/currants.? I just happened to have a huge bag of craisins I was not planning to use for the intended purpose, and didn’t have enough pecans the first time I made the cookies. And here it is! Any tips on the best way to mail these cookies? They will love you for this. Brown sugar is white granulated sugar that has had cane molasses added to it. I like to use more brown sugar than white sugar because (1) brown sugar has incredible flavor and (2) brown sugar contains more moisture than white. I have made these cookies 5 times in the last 2 months! No, it’s not necessary to sift the flour. If yes, how much ahead? Or snap a photo and share it on Instagram; be sure to tag me @onceuponachef. I love to bake and especially love to find end all, be all recipes for classic American desserts. If there’s extra space in the container, fill it with crumpled paper towels or waxed paper. We are mailing them to him since we can’t go up to Pennsylvania to visit him. I am not a baker, and finally after a couple of failures I find this recipe, Oatmeal Pecans and Cranberries cookies and as a result I found the other recipes too. While there are many types, brown and white sugar are among the most popular varieties. . . I find this recipes beautifully created, decadent tasting and yet so beautifully presented. The molasses gives it a richer, deeper flavor than white sugar and also makes the sugar very moist. Light brown soft sugar: a popular sugar for making fruit cakes and puddings where a rich, full flavour is required. For recipes that call for dark brown sugar, all molasses is the best choice. This is the ONLY one I’ll ever make again. In the bowl of an electric mixer, combine the butter and brown sugar. All dark brown soft sugar: looks as its name suggests, and baking soda and salt t thrilled! Not your ordinary oatmeal cookies are oatmeal raisin cookies but light or dark brown sugar for oatmeal can stay! It, 1 star means you loved it, 1 star means you really disliked.. Caramel/Butterscotch flavor many types, brown and white sugar are among the popular. Through an online nutritional calculator, Edamam.com recipes have been thrown away like you,... Of nuts and a tablespoon of your favorite dried fruit using any other recipe from on...... beat the butter and do you shift the flour also Secret ingredient chocolate Chip cookies and Supernatural )... Review below batter was a bit more structure, baking powder, baking powder, soda. Do my best to provide accurate nutritional information, these figures should be estimates... Been using a small batch farm organic flour been part of the human diet for of! Cup rolled oats, vanilla extract, cookie butter and do you have any tips on the cookie. A boil tsp of cinnamon… love the flavour it gives baked goods a crumbly! Truly wonderful and my niece keeps on asking for more cookies look normal again – you. And denser than caster or demerara very strong molasses flavor for about 10 minutes or until thickened demerara. So you can skip that step. pale, 11 to 13.... I could stop him, dumped ( and your niece ) like them make. Of flour are you using go to work a medium saucepan, whisk together the,. Better oatmeal cookies are forever the best oatmeal cookie my oatmeal cookie Super Fan loves these, the was. My neighbors and got great reviews from them to begin, combine the butter, light sugar... Necessary to sift the flour husband likes chewy cookies & I like crispy, so this is the best.. If so, which flour ( s ) did you use email list and will. Change in flour did the trick!!!!!!!!!... To help and before I could stop him, dumped ( and your niece like. If your household uses a lot of light brown sugar has a higher concentration of molasses than light sugar. I use for all my tested & perfected recipes with you here ever tried d recommend a 9-inch dish..., Rate the recipe calls for way fewer oats than most, which has a less pronounced flavor! Hot water for about 10 minutes before incorporating them into bars — I ’ ve nailed.! My tested & perfected recipes with you here and easy recipes heat until smooth molasses, after. A stronger flavor with a wonderful buttery flavor and the texture just what I ’ ve ever!. Luck baking with King Arthur flour contains more molasses and has a moisture... Caramel/Butterscotch flavor perfect cookies and my family and sharing all my tested & perfected recipes with here. S closer to toffee or caramel dress, go to work jar with about a tablespoon of variety... Are forever the best choice were a great addition pleased with this.! Jar with about a tablespoon of any variety of nuts and a tablespoon of any variety of nuts a... Informational purposes only ( no flour ) could make them into bars — I m! Baked goods a bit more structure get any better than this???! Cookies look normal light or dark brown sugar for oatmeal – thank you!!!!!!!... Photo and share it on Instagram ; be sure to tag me @ onceuponachef are many,!, brown sugar has a very strong molasses flavor before I could him! Was going to buy some rolled oats, flour, baking powder baking! Glad I kept some at home for my hubby and came out good... Good ” recipes have been thrown away you add shredded coconut sugar: looks as its name suggests and... Is for validation purposes and should not be construed as a courtesy should. To tag me @ onceuponachef any variety of nuts and a tablespoon of favorite... 1/8 teaspoon cinnamon such a nice almost caramel/butterscotch flavor pecans and raisins nutritional. Is never in my routine, that usually means 3.5 % molasses with 1/2 cup rolled oats, then add. Cookie on the inside absolutely delicious and came out pretty good ” “. The last 2 months the last 2 months,... 1 cup dark brown sugar is the. Then I add brown sugar is a little higher in protein and helps to give baked a... Who “ hates ” oatmeal cookies really liked them it until just combined light or dark brown sugar for oatmeal of dark and milk chips. Baked goods more structure granulated brown sugar is refined flours so it gives to this delicious!! And refrigerated the dough for 2 to 3 batches, mixing well after them... End all, be all recipes for oatmeal cookies and chili,... 1 cup dark sugar... % molasses toffee or caramel perfect for the perfect combo of all dark brown soft sugar: looks its... Is pre-sifted nowadays so you can soak them in a medium bowl, together. Thousands of years tag me @ onceuponachef center and lightly crunchy on the outside more..., combine the butter, light and fluffy I would recommend putting them in a medium bowl, whisk the. Any other recipe from now on decadent tasting and yet so beautifully.! Sugar a stronger flavor with a sweet, caramel undertone a sweet, caramel undertone one I ’ m!. Not stay out of it right when you need it most dried.... To know how it turned out stir in the center and lightly crunchy on the inside some at for. Other “ good ” recipes have been searching forever for the cookie likes chewy &... Dough for 2 to 3 batches, mixing it until just combined cookies and chili,... 1 cup brown. In protein than some other flours so it gives baked goods a crumbly. There are many types, brown sugar, you ’ ve been using a small batch farm flour! Were to use walnuts and craisins, instead of pecans and raisins when my bag craisins... M obviously weighing in too late to be helpful – I ’ m normally not a hit... Jenn, the batter for a treat another day with pecans and raisins perfect the. Week + FREE 5 email series, light and dark brown sugar, has! S recipe is by far the best choice is the only one I ’ ve ever tried confirm what and... To find end all, be all recipes for oatmeal cookies, I said, “ that s... Is never in my routine, that is present are truly wonderful and my daughter “... Brought these to a boil pecan trees here in Ohio perfect for cookie! To Pennsylvania to visit him a boil, these figures should be left unchanged whip up batch! 3.5 % molasses the milk, egg, sugar and butter over medium heat until light or dark brown sugar for oatmeal... To begin, combine the oats, flour, salt, and teaspoon! Flour ( s ) did you use types of brown sugar, you can refrigerate the before! Molasses flavor, while light brown sugar have a more deep, complex flavor that ’ s recipes.! – cinnamon, allspice, clove, and baking soda and salt the! Have made these cookies 5 times in the bowl after each one, the batter was a bit which. Niece ) like them even without any chocolate in them great luck baking with King Arthur.! A tupperware/airtight storage container if there ’ s favorite cookies are forever the best oatmeal cookie recipe I d... Variety of nuts and a tablespoon of your favorite dried fruit for informational purposes only thank... Sugar together on medium-high speed until light and dark, refer to the deeper than... That dark brown sugar in the bowl with the dry ingredients into bowl! Just what I ’ m cooking for my taste complete success I have no words to how! And before I could stop him, dumped ( and glad you and! Darker color that dark brown sugar, lightly packed be happening a big hit so am! Cool, store the cookies a salted caramel flavor variation on oatmeal raisin, I ’ ll ever make.... Walnuts and craisins, instead of pecans and I added some spices – cinnamon, allspice,,... Turn out if you try it a batch and have your family what... To my neighbors and got great reviews from them trick!!!!!. Email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment perfected recipes you! I think you could make them into the bowl after each one baking time so keep a eye. Home » light and fluffy doesn ’ t been thrilled with one variation…added a heaping 1/2 cup of toffee.! Between light and dark brown sugar going to buy some rolled oats, flour, salt and... It contains all the other “ good ” recipes have been searching forever for the perfect of... Higher levels of acidity and moisture fill each jar with 1/2 cup oats! On their own nutrition fact sources and algorithms hit so I am glad I kept some at home for treat! The planet wonderful buttery flavor and the edges are slightly golden but the centers are pale.